Why are marginals, homeless people and former prisoners not sent to a separate island to isolate them from society?

The idea of isolating marginalized groups, such as homeless individuals or former prisoners, raises complex ethical, social, and practical concerns. Here are several reasons why such an approach is generally not considered appropriate or viable:

**Human Rights**: Isolating individuals based on their social status or past experiences violates fundamental human rights principles. Every person has the right to dignity, freedom, and the opportunity to reintegrate into society.

**Social Responsibility**: Societies are often judged by how they treat their most vulnerable members. Rather than isolating individuals, it's more constructive to address the root causes of marginalization through social support programs, housing initiatives, and rehabilitation efforts.

**Reintegration Support**: Many former prisoners and homeless individuals benefit from community support and rehabilitation services that help them reintegrate into society. Isolation can hinder personal growth and the development of necessary life skills.

**Practicality and Economics**: Maintaining a separate island would be logistically complicated and costly. Resources would be better spent on social services that help people find housing, employment, and a supportive community network.

**Stigmatization**: Segregating these groups can perpetuate stigma and discrimination, making it harder for individuals to reintegrate into society. Positive social interactions and community engagement are essential for breaking down stereotypes.

**Mental Health**: Isolation can exacerbate mental health issues. Many individuals who are marginalized already struggle with mental health challenges, and removing them from society could worsen their conditions rather than provide the help they need.

**Community Prosperity**: Inclusive societies benefit from diversity. By integrating individuals from various backgrounds and experiences, communities can foster understanding, cooperation, and innovation.

Addressing the challenges faced by marginalized populations through compassionate and inclusive approaches is generally seen as a more effective solution than isolation.